Saber CEO Matt Karch’s Fiery Reply to AI-Firing Claim Called “Remarkably Pathetic”

Saber Interactive CEO Matthew Karch has escalated a public dispute with a former staff writer instead of calming it, firing off a combative statement that the writer, Stella Sacco, has since branded “remarkably pathetic.” The row centres on Sacco’s claim that she was pulled off the studio’s upcoming driving game, Rideshare “Stimulator,” and replaced by ChatGPT partway through development.
Sacco, who says she worked as Saber’s lead writer from July 2023 to July 2024 on Stuntman: Hollywood and other games across Saber’s portfolio, went public after spotting the reveal trailer for Rideshare “Stimulator.” According to This Week in Videogames, she posted on Bluesky in the early hours of August 12, writing that she had been “lead writer on this one! And Saber replaced me with ChatGPT midway through development. All the passenger voices were AI too.”
A Trailer Jab at Randy Pitchford Set Off the Row
The controversy surfaced after reports that the Rideshare “Stimulator” trailer contained a pointed joke aimed at Gearbox boss Randy Pitchford, tied to the fallout from Embracer Group’s handling of Borderlands 4. Video Games Chronicle reported that Saber CEO Matt Karch confirmed that the jokes in the trailer were indeed aimed at Pitchford, but the story caught the eye of former lead writer Stella Sacco, who then claimed on Bluesky that she had been replaced on Rideshare ‘Stimulator’ in favour of AI writing tools.
It wasn’t the first time Sacco had raised the subject. Kotaku noted that this isn’t the first time Sacco has shared her experience with genAI during her time at Saber Interactive, having posted back in December that she had been “replaced” by ChatGPT on an unnamed game. This time, however, she named the title directly.
Saber’s First Response: “Written Entirely by Real People”
Saber’s PR team initially sent a written denial to PC Gamer rejecting the core allegation. The statement read: “Neither Saber nor Unigine have replaced any writers with AI for Rideshare or any other game. In fact, Saber’s staff of writers has tripled since 2023. Rideshare’s story was written entirely by real people.”
The same statement, though, conceded that generative AI does have a role in the game. Saber told PC Gamer that the game will also feature an experimental, free-ride mode that by necessity incorporates AI as the number of passengers in the game is infinite, adding it has used AI tools “to improve or enhance gameplay experiences and improve NPC behavior” since the studio’s founding in 2001. The company added a pointed reassurance to staff: as the industry has continued to contract, Saber continues to hire, and none of its more than 3,000 employees have to worry about being replaced by AI.
Despite that admission, PC Gamer noted the game’s storefront page still carried no AI notice, reporting that despite the admission, there’s currently no AI disclosure on the Rideshare “Stimulator” Steam page. In a follow-up, Saber told the outlet “the Steam page will be updated once the feature set is finalized,” insisting “we are touting this experimental mode as a feature, not shying away from it.”
Karch’s Follow-Up Statement Names Sacco and Turns Personal
Rather than let the PR statement stand, Karch personally sent a second, longer statement to This Week in Videogames that dropped any pretence of measured corporate language. Aftermath, which reviewed the same statement, described it as four paragraphs blending personal and deeply unprofessional insults with further admissions to the use of AI in Rideshare “Stimulator,” despite the game’s Steam page containing no AI disclosures.
Karch opened by questioning whether he even knew who Sacco was, saying “Stella who? I had to ask Claude because I have never spoken to her or seen her. We have already said we are using AI for certain parts of the game and will update the Steam page once we have finalized the feature set.” He went on to argue that the writing credit for the finished game belonged to someone else entirely, stating “let me clarify that the entire story script, were it to win an award, would go to someone who can walk up on stage and receive it. It was always our intention to reveal this until Stella violated her confidentiality clause and revealed this before we were ready.”
The CEO’s statement, as quoted by Aftermath, also took direct aim at Sacco personally: “We look at our use of AI in this particular game, which will be a lower priced title, as a plus for consumers,” he said. “As far as Stella is concerned, she was replaced by someone more talented and terminated for a variety of reasons a few months later. From what I can gather she enjoys controversy even more than I do. I would frankly in retrospect have been happy to replace her with AI. At least we would be dealing with someone programmed to be honest.”
Sacco Fires Back: “Everything I Said Was True”
Sacco didn’t let the CEO’s statement go unanswered. Posting again on Bluesky the following morning, she stood by her original account and turned Karch’s own rhetoric back on him. As captured by Aftermath, she wrote: “Everything I said was true. Here’s more truth: that statement is remarkably pathetic for the CEO of any company to be making, and combined with the AI use it will do far more damage to Saber’s reputation than it ever could mine.”
She also pushed back earlier in the saga on Saber’s initial denial, telling PC Gamer plainly: “They can say what they want—I was there, I even posted on Facebook about it at the time,” maintaining she had documented her account of events well before the public dispute broke out.
Why the Disclosure Gap Matters for Steam Buyers
Beyond the personal back-and-forth, the episode lands squarely in an ongoing industry argument over how publishers should disclose generative AI content on storefronts like Steam, where regional buyers: including those browsing from New Zealand and Australia, rely on listing pages to understand what they’re purchasing. Valve has required AI-content disclosures on Steam listings since 2024, and Saber’s admission that its own Rideshare “Stimulator” page has yet to reflect the tech already built into the game is likely to keep scrutiny on the title as its release approaches.
For now, neither side shows signs of dropping the dispute, and with Karch’s statement circulating widely among developers and writers across the industry, the fallout for Saber’s reputation may prove harder to manage than the original allegation ever was.







Join the Conversation